China accuses Australia, UK and US of ‘double standards’ over security pact
French president Emmanuel Macron and then Australian prime minister Malcolm Turnbull (centre) standing on the deck of HMAS Waller, a submarine operated by the Royal Australian Navy, at Garden Island in Sydney in 2018. Photograph: Brendan Esposito/POOL/AFP via Getty Images
China has hit out at Australia, the UK and US for playing “geopolitical games” after they struck a new security pact to let Canberra acquire nuclear-powered submarines.
Zhao Lijian, China’s foreign ministry spokesman, accused the three countries on Thursday of double standards and an “outdated cold war zero-sum mentality”.
The comments show the extreme sensitivity of the Aukus partnership, which US allies such as Taiwan and Japan hailed for its potential to offset an increasingly assertive China.
Paris also reacted to the deal with fury, but for different reasons, after Canberra cancelled a A$90 billion (€55 billion) programme to acquire 12 conventionally powered submarines from France.
Australia will instead procure at least eight nuclear-powered submarines, which are faster, stealthier and able to operate over longer ranges.
Describing the agreement as the biggest initiative in Australian defence policy since its alliance with the US in 1951, Scott Morrison, prime minister, said it was a “forever partnership . . . between the oldest and most trusted of friends”.
Canberra also intends to buy Tomahawk cruise missiles for its navy, and air-launched cruise missiles for the Royal Australian Air Force, said Mr Morrison.
Officials in Taipei, which is on the frontline of tensions between Washington and Beijing, said the pact would help balance China’s growing military strength and assertiveness.
“Keeping the Indo Pacific free and open is not just important for the security of neighbouring countries like Taiwan, it’s essential for today’s interconnected global economy,” said Kolas Yotaka, spokeswoman for Taiwan’s president Tsai Ing-wen.
“So broader involvement by members of the international community is a positive and necessary trend for peace and stability in the region.”
A Taiwanese national security official welcomed the shift in Australian strategy. “The creation of Aukus fills the most important gap in the security web of the entire western Pacific,” the official said.
Taro Kono, a former Japanese foreign and defence minister and a leading candidate to succeed Yoshihide Suga as prime minister, said Tokyo also had to partner with allies to address China’s military expansion.
“We very much welcome that the UK is once again turning its eyes to the Pacific region,” Mr Kono told reporters. “It is extremely important for Japan to work closely with these three countries.”
China has rapidly modernised its military over the past two decades and used the People’s Liberation Army’s capabilities to assert territorial claims and threaten several of its neighbours.
Chinese military aircraft fly almost daily incursions into the air defence identification zone of Taiwan, which Beijing claims as part of its territory and threatens to invade if Taipei refuses unification indefinitely.
A person familiar with the discussions said Australia had pushed Washington to provide the nuclear propulsion technology and that the initiative was not proposed to Canberra by the Biden administration.
The person said Australia concluded that the “rapidly changing strategic environment” required more capable vessels than a conventionally powered submarine.
A second person familiar with the situation said Washington and Canberra had both notified France ahead of the decision. But Paris reacted bitterly, highlighting the risk that Washington was offending one ally to draw closer to another.
“This decision is contrary to the letter and spirit of the co-operation that prevailed between France and Australia,” said Jean-Yves Le Drian, the foreign minister, and defence minister Florence Parly, adding that it reinforced the need to establish an autonomous European strategy.
“The American choice to exclude a European ally and partner such as France . . . shows a lack of coherence that France can only note and regret.”
Jacinda Ardern, the prime minister of New Zealand, insisted the pact would not undermine arrangements such as the Five Eyes intelligence-sharing partnership, which includes New Zealand and Canada as well as the Aukus countries.
“No, we weren’t approached but nor would I expect us to be,” said Ms Ardern. “This is not a treaty-level arrangement. It does not change our existing relationships including Five Eyes or our close partnership with Australia on defence matters.”
In line with New Zealand law, she added, the nuclear-powered Australian submarines would not be allowed to enter New Zealand’s waters. – Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2021