France’s odd game on renewables
Welcome to EURACTIV’s Green Brief, our weekly selection of energy and environment news from across Europe. To subscribe, follow this link. You can also subscribe to our daily newsletter here and to our comprehensive weekly update here.
The French government reaffirmed last week that it does not want to choose between nuclear and renewables, saying it is taking action to promote both.
Yet, its challenge to the EU’s revised Renewable Energy Directive, launched at the last minute last week before the text was due to be formally approved in the Council of the European Union, reveals aggressive pro-nuclear lobbying that risks destabilising investments in decarbonisation – a move which goes against France’s proclaimed objectives.
The sequence of events is telling. On Tuesday afternoon (16 May), the National Assembly adopted a bill to revive the nuclear industry, presented by Energy Transition Minister Agnès Pannier-Runacher.
In the morning, Pannier-Runacher had previously met with representatives of 16 European states as part of the “nuclear alliance“, a group of pro-nuclear countries. The meeting concluded with a joint statement urging the EU to support policies to revive European nuclear power. In the same breath, Pannier-Runacher announced France’s intention to join the “renewables friendly” group of EU countries.
By accident or design, a report circulated in Brussels the next day stating that France was blocking discussions on the EU’s Renewable Energy Directive, even though a political agreement had been reached with the European Parliament on 30 March, almost two months before.
France, backed by other EU member states, was asking for further “guarantees” on low-carbon hydrogen derived from nuclear power. Indeed, the EU deal on the renewables directive recognises that EU member states with a low-carbon (nuclear) electricity mix can benefit from adjustments in meeting their renewable hydrogen production targets – a victory for France and its allies.
Specifically, Paris seeks to “clarify the changes introduced by Belgium and the Netherlands on the implementation of hydrogen objectives,” Pannier-Runacher’s office told EURACTIV. According to the French hydrogen industry, this would involve adjusting rules for the production of ammonia, a hydrogen derivative, which is very difficult to decarbonise by electrolysis.
But a more fundamental point has caught the attention of French decision-makers. According to most experts, the exemption for nuclear-derived hydrogen in the revised renewables directive was a Pyrrhic victory for France because the criteria were simply too difficult to meet.
From that perspective, France’s last-minute objection to the directive appears more like a riposte, a move to obtain further concessions on nuclear-derived hydrogen.
At home, die-hard supporters of nuclear power – who often tend to disparage renewables – applauded the move, claiming that France’s simultaneous manoeuvre to join the “renewables friendly” group of EU countries was “a strategic mistake“.
Fortunately, not all nuclear fans in France share such extreme views.
Maxence Cordiez, an engineer at the French Atomic Energy Commission, tweeted that the presence of France in the renewables-friendly group “will ensure that it respects the vocation stated in its name” and prevent it from transforming into “an alliance of opposition to nuclear power”.
Even within the ranks of the French ruling majority, some expressed surprise at the method chosen.
French MEP Christophe Grudler, the speaker on renewables for the centrist Renew group in the European Parliament and a supporter of French President Emmanuel Macron, said he regretted the delay to the directive’s final adoption. “It is NOW that our renewable industries in Europe need clear rules!” said Grudler, a staunch nuclear defender.
Worse, European diplomats said France was using the same methods as Germany, which was heavily criticised in December for reopening an interinstitutional agreement on car emission rules that introduced a ban on the sale of petrol and diesel engines by 2035.
There is no doubt that the German precedent has opened a loophole which the “big” EU countries can now use whenever they are not satisfied with an agreed text, according to one of the diplomats. It is a “bad day for democracy,” one of them even told us.
More fundamentally, the move raises questions in Brussels about France’s true commitment to renewables. Is it consistent with its desire to join the “renewables-friendly” group of EU countries?
There is no doubt that the French strategy is to restore the image of nuclear power, which it considers indispensable for achieving the EU’s long-term climate objective – a reduction in emissions to net zero by 2050.
While this seems necessary, France’s strange game appears to be confusing Brussels and ultimately ends up harming its credibility.
Today’s edition is powered by CEN & CENELEC
Standards, driving the future of CleanTech in Europe
On 8 June, CEN and CENELEC are organising a one-day stakeholder workshop that will explore how standards can support the manufacturing of clean technologies and ensure Europe can succeed in the green transition. Register here >>
No destroying unsold goods: EU countries agree on green product rules
The EU’s 27 countries have agreed a common position on the revamp of the bloc’s sustainable product rules, following strenuous negotiations about a sweeping ban on the destruction of unsold textiles and footwear.
Nuclear alliance aims for 150 GW of nuclear capacity in EU by 2050
The 16 European countries participating in the “nuclear alliance” will prepare a roadmap to develop an integrated European nuclear industry reaching 150 GW of nuclear power capacity in the EU’s electricity mix by 2050.
Key lawmaker wants revenue cap in EU electricity market reform
The European Parliament’s lead negotiator for reforming Europe’s power market has caused concern by proposing the return of a controversial revenue cap in times of crisis for power generators with cheap production costs, like renewables and nuclear.
PARIS. French government presents its decarbonisation plan to meet EU targets. On Monday, French Prime Minister Elisabeth Borne unveiled France’s greenhouse gas emission reduction targets to meet the EU’s 55% reduction target by 2030. Read more.
BERLIN. Franco-German friendship meeting overshadowed by nuclear divide. The Franco-German Parliamentary Assembly on Monday, where 50 French National Assembly members and 50 Bundestag members meet bi-annually to foster cooperation between the countries, was overshadowed by their divides on nuclear energy. Read more.
BRUSSELS | BERLIN. Belgium’s De Croo slams degrowth, joins call for a regulatory break. Belgian Prime Minister Alexander De Croo criticised the idea of not growing the economy for environmental reasons at a business congress in Berlin on Monday, joining calls to stop environmental and health-related regulation to prevent overburdening companies. Read more.
PRAGUE. Czech-led coalition of eight countries opposes Euro 7 cars emissions standards. A coalition of eight countries, led by Czechia, has come together to voice strong criticism against the proposed Euro 7 car emission standards. Read more.
SOFIA. Bulgaria banks on Western technology to use its Russian nuclear reactors. Bulgaria has not shelved plans to build a second nuclear power plant on the banks of the Danube River with Russian nuclear reactors it purchased from the country six years ago, hoping that Western technology could make the reactors work now that Moscow’s participation is impossible. Read more.
BUCHAREST. Illegal logging data from Romania contradictory, says EU Parliament delegation. The data Romanian authorities sent to a delegation of the European Parliament’s Petitions Committee that visited several Romanian counties last week to view the impact of illegal deforestation on the ground were contradictory, members of the delegation have said. Read more.
BUCHAREST. Romania, Republic of Moldova to expand Iasi-Ungheni-Chisinau gas pipeline. The Romanian and Moldovan governments signed a memorandum about the interconnection of natural gas and electricity networks between their countries, through the expansion of the Iasi-Ungheni-Chisinau gas pipeline. Read more.
- Green industry law haunted by old conflicts over nuclear, financing – Jonathan Packroff
- Critical Raw Materials: EU ministers want to move fast but dilemmas abound – János Allenbach-Ammann
- Lawmaker mulls scrapping EU’s draft raw material domestic production targets – Oliver Noyan
- Energy Taxation Directive: Europe’s key climate law stuck in a quagmire – Jonathan Packroff and Nikolaus J. Kurmayer
- The French government’s plan to make its industry greener – Davide Basso and Théophane Hartmann
- German top-level official Graichen steps down amid cronyism allegations – Nikolaus J. Kurmayer
Ozone treaty delayed Arctic ice-free summer by 15 years: research. The 1987 Montreal Protocol, a UN treaty aimed at protecting the Earth’s ozone layer, has successfully delayed the first ice-free Arctic summer by up to 15 years, according to new research.
Ozone-depleting substances such as chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) are also potent greenhouse gases, so the deal has also helped slow global warming, said the researchers from UC Santa Cruz, Columbia University and the University of Exeter who conducted the study.
According to their estimates, each 1,000 tonnes of ODS emissions prevented saves about seven square kilometres of Arctic sea ice.
“ODSs have particularly powerful effects in the Arctic, and they played a major role in driving Arctic climate change in the second half of the 20th Century,” said Dr Mark England, a senior research fellow at the University of Exeter who took part in the study.
“While stopping these effects was not the primary goal of the Montreal Protocol, it has been a fantastic by-product,” he said in a statement.
The paper, published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, is entitled: “The Montreal Protocol is delaying the occurrence of the first ice-free Arctic summer.” Once published, the paper will be available here.
(Frédéric Simon | EURACTIV.com)
- After the energy storm, Europe needs strong industrial strategy – By Georg Zachmann, Giovanni Sgaravatti and Simone Tagliapietra
- Bringing efficiency in the EU’s National Energy and Climate Plans – By Monica Frassoni
- Eastern EU countries will make or break the bloc’s 2030 renewables goal – By Pawel Czyzak and Rebekka Popp
JUNE
- JUNE. European Parliament plenary vote on EU Nature Restoration Law.
- 1 JUNE. Gas package trilogue.
- 3-11 JUNE. EU Green Week.
- 6 JUNE. First EPBD trilogue.
- 19 JUNE. Energy Council.
- 20-22 June 2023. EU Sustainable Energy Week
- 20 JUNE. Environment Council.
- 21 JUNE. Greening transport package.
- 29-30 JUNE. European Council.
- 30 JUNE. Deadline for European Member States to update their revised National Energy and Climate Plans (NECPs).
SECOND HALF OF 2023
- Q4. Revision of REACH regulation.
- OCTOBER. European Parliament plenary vote on Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation.
- 26-27 OCTOBER. European Council.
- 30 NOVEMBER-12 DECEMBER. UN Climate Change Conference (COP 28), Dubai.
- 14-15 DECEMBER. European Council.
Read more with EURACTIV
