It’s a Match!
Greetings from the European Council premises! While EU leaders are still too busy to discuss the economic future of the bloc, we at EURACTIV want to offer you, our esteemed Economy Brief reader, a quick guide on how to squeeze the most state aid out of your government.
EU competition chief Margrethe Vestager is not a fan of subsidies.
If this hadn’t been clear to you already, you could see it clearly when she announced changes to the EU’s state aid rules last week.
“At the end of the day, state aid is the transfer of money from taxpayers to shareholders,” she said, warning that her own proposals are “a serious risk to competition” and therefore ought to be ‘temporary’ – a word she repeated 14 times in her press conference.
But Vestager was under pressure from the German and French governments as well as their respective nationals within the Commission, who happen to be the Internal Market Commissioner Thierry Breton and the President, Ursula von der Leyen.
The new rules will, among other things, allow EU countries to ‘match’ foreign subsidies to prevent green tech production sites from being built abroad instead of within the EU.
So – if you happen to build a solar factory, a heat pump production, a battery plant or something similar – good news for you!
The principle, you might know from your Saturday shopping: When you tell the electronics store on the main street that a well-known (American!) online marketplace offers a cheaper price – and if you ask sufficiently politely – they might be willing to ‘match’ the price to keep you in the shop.
But just like in retail, where not every store will be able to afford to make such deals to keep you as a customer, not every EU country will be able to afford subsidy-’matching’.
Thus, over the last weeks, concerns were voiced that those countries with bigger pockets could benefit the most from such an option.
Above all is Germany, which accounted for over half of the state aid authorised in the EU under the current crisis emergency framework.
Vestager found a shrewd way aiming to prevent this from happening.
She limited the allowed amount of state aid that an individual country can grant per project to €100 million. Economically weaker regions will be granted more flexibility – with sums of €150 million or even €300 million allowed.
If you want to go above the 300 mark, you not only have to ask the Commission for individual permission, you stand no chance if you do not either plan your factory in one of the EU’s poorest regions – or if you find production sites in at least three other EU countries to partner up with.
And you better ask politely – you don’t want to end up being blamed for “blackmail” by German Handelsblatt.
Here are the lists of all the regions for each member state. You want to look out for category ‘a’ for everything above €300 million and category ‘c’ to at least get to squeeze €150 million out of your government.
To make your life easier and avoid spending hours making sense of the Commission’s literature database, please find below a map of countries that would be affected by the ‘go-alone’ limit.
EURACTIV did not get any response from the European Commission on whether this had anything to do with the fear of a German spending spree – but we expect that it wasn’t immune.
But before you run to your government now, keep in mind that this is just a proposal.
There’s still a summit of EU leaders happening today (9 February) which is meant to discuss the issue – EU leaders just have to finish their meeting with Zelenskyy and solve the migration issue first, but that shouldn’t take too long, right?
So maybe this is a good moment to first ask a foreign government what they have to offer.
The map shows which EU countries have so-called category ‘a’ regions, in which national governments would be allowed to match foreign subsidies even above €150 million on their own.
For investments in all other regions, member states have to work together – either with a category ‘a’ region in a different country or with at least 3 other member states.
“Solidarity” and joint borrowing scrapped from EU leaders’ summit statement. Faced with mounting concerns about the competitiveness of European industries, EU leaders had aimed to discuss industrial policy at today’s (9 February) European Council. But as the focus of EU leaders’ attention shifts away from the economic debate towards migration and the war in Ukraine, a paragraph on economic “solidarity” and a “fully effective EU policy response” to the US Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) was deleted from the draft conclusions. It also included a reference to the SURE programme, a joint borrowing scheme that during the Covid-crisis allowed member states with traditionally higher interest rates more favourable borrowing conditions. Read more.
EU auditors warn of risks in using cohesion policy to address crises. According to a report by the European Court of Auditors (ECA), while the use of cohesion policy funds was crucial to cope with the pandemic, their repeated use to address crises risks undermining their long-term aim. Although its primary objective is to reduce development disparities between regions, cohesion policy has been used to address various crises since 2009. “This relaxation of rules brings some risks and challenges and I think it is about time to start learning lessons from these repeated crises that we face,” ECA member Iliana Ivanova told EURACTIV.
European citizens see high income inequality in their country, survey shows. According to a new Eurobarometer survey, 81% of European citizens believe income inequality is too high in their country and more than 7 in 10 respondents call on the EU or their government to address the issue. The survey also found that 78% of Europeans would like more public spending on social policies, such as healthcare, education, pensions and housing.
Non-compete clauses for workers: Will the EU follow the US lead? In January, the US competition authority proposed to ban non-compete clauses in employment contracts, calling it “a widespread and often exploitative practice that suppresses wages, hampers innovation, and blocks entrepreneurs from starting new businesses.” While the EU’s competition chief Margrethe Vestager said there were “not that many” in the EU as there were in the US, studies point to several millions of Europeans working under the restrictive conditions of an anti-compete clause. Read more.
EU lawmakers call for more investments in skills development. In a draft report adopted on Monday (6 February), MEPs from the employment committee called on the EU to step up skills development in the EU workforce and agreed to enter into interinstitutional negotiations for the European Year of Skills 2023. In the text, EU lawmakers urge to increase investments in lifelong learning and training in order to boost the EU economy’s competitiveness.
Italian government pours €125 billion into healthcare. Staff shortages and long waiting lists for treatment have prompted the Italian government to allocate €125 billion to the national health system, announced Health Minister Orazio Schillaci on Wednesday. Read more.
French minister: International trade faces ‘paradigm shift’, EU industrial plan key. Trading with international partners at “whatever costs” no longer makes sense, French Trade Minister Olivier Becht said, expressing his support that the EU must react to the US Inflation Reduction Act with its own industrial plan. Read more.
Gentiloni asks member states to amend recovery plans ‘quickly’. EU Economy Commissioner Paolo Gentiloni called on EU member states to summarise the changes of their recovery plans in a single amendment in order to speed up the approval process and the actual implementation. Read more.
Czechia wants to avoid EU subsidy race, prefers negotiations with US. Entering a subsidy race by loosening state aid rules to compete with the US is something Czech officials, including its industry chief, wants to avoid. Read more.
Slovak growth tied to recovery plan’s success. Growth will depend on whether Slovakia will be able to absorb EU recovery fund money, according to experts, after the National Bank of Slovakia upped its growth forecast from the previous 0.6% to 1.3%. Read more.
Bulgarian government introduces food price controls. Bulgaria will introduce a mechanism to monitor and control food prices across the entire supply chain, caretaker Prime Minister Galab Donev, after a meeting with ministers and representatives of consumer organisations on Tuesday. Read more.
Dutch present priority areas for EU critical raw material strategy. Ahead of a Commission proposal due in March, the Dutch laid out five priority areas for a “coherent” EU critical raw material strategy to ensure the transition to a green economy and decrease dependence on China. Read more.
France’s Le Maire, Germany’s Habeck head to Washington to defend EU interests. French and German Economy Ministers Bruno Le Maire and Robert Habeck will visit Washington on Monday to defend the European Commission’s latest moves to counter the US’ controversial granting of green subsidies through the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA). Read more.
Finland should triple net immigration, says think tank. Plagued with an ageing population and a low fertility rate, Finland would need three times more immigrants than projected to boost growth and improve public finances, according to ETLA Economic Research, an independent, private and non-profit economic research institute. Read more.
Spain nearly at pre-pandemic tourism levels. Spain received a total of 71.6 million tourists in 2022, which is 14.3% less than the number of tourists welcomed in 2019, the year before the pandemic broke out, official figures revealed. Read more.
Stories, statistics, and memory. Widespread misperceptions shape attitudes on key societal topics, such as climate change and the Covid-19 pandemic. These belief distortions are puzzling in contexts where accurate statistical information is broadly available and attended to. Thomas Graeber, Christopher Roth and Florian Zimmermann argue that the nature of human memory may be key for understanding the persistence of misperceptions in practice.
Addressing the challenges of the healthcare workforce: Ensuring the future of health in Europe. A Policy Brief by the European Policy Centre (EPC) identifies the challenges facing the European healthcare workforce and possible solutions. It argues that to address the diminishing capacity of Europe’s health workforce, national investment in the health labour force is necessary.